lunes, 16 de noviembre de 2026

The Axe, the Symbol, and the Open Wound: A Surgical Reading of the Agency of Art from Amazonia

 

Bernabé Mallo

Doctor en Filosofía por la Universidad del País Vasco (UPV/EHU)
Investigador en neurofilosofía, evolución humana y origen del arte. / PhD in Philosophy – University of the Basque Country (UPV/EHU)
Researcher in neurophilosophy, human evolution, and the origins of art.

 

A review of Ardis da Arte: Imagem, agência e ritual na Amazônia by Carlos Fausto 

 

Some books are read, and some books operate. Ardis da Arte, by the anthropologist Carlos Fausto, belongs to the second category. Beneath the appearance of an ethnographic study of images and ritual artifacts in Indigenous Amazonia, there lies a more ambitious intervention: that of a researcher who, after decades of living with the Parakanã and the Kuikuro, refuses to treat art as a cultural ornament added onto social life. Fausto describes a world in which staffs “become spirits” and humans “become jaguars”; a world, in short, where images do not represent: they act. The question that this book leaves hanging in the air is not what an image means, but what an image does when it is introduced into a field of ritual forces, and why human beings have invested so much energy, from the Paleolithic to the present, in producing objects that seem to have a will of their own.

For a researcher working at the intersection of neuroscience, philosophy, and the anthropology of art, the most honest answer to that question cannot be content with a culturalist explanation. Fausto offers empirical evidence that the agency of images is a robust ethnographic fact; what he does not offer—because it is not his task—is a hypothesis about the neural and evolutionary conditions that make it possible for a wooden artifact or a painted stone to become an ontological operator. It is here that the S/Y/C framework on the origin of art in the Homo species ceases to be one theoretical framework among others and reveals itself as a dissecting tool. The S/Y/C Law of Biological Coherence that sustains this research postulates that the nervous system operates through a primordial function subdivided into three inseparable subfunctions: Survival (S) , as the physical threshold that every biological action must cross; Symbolon (Y) , as the capacity to contain, create, and manipulate shared codes that bridge the internal and external worlds; and Completeness (C) , as the driving force toward the integration of parts into a meaningful whole. Applied to the Amazonian material, this triad does not function as a taxonomic grid but as a surgical protocol: Fausto’s ritual image is, in terms of the S/Y/C model, an optimal solution in which Symbolon satisfies the demands of Completeness without compromising the substrate of Survival that sustains the group’s life. The staff that “becomes a spirit” is not a poetic metaphor: it is a device of biological coherence, an object that allows the individual nervous system and the social body to stabilize a relationship with the environment that would otherwise be intolerably dispersed.

The Surgical Philosophy that articulates this research is not a rhetorical game. It unfolds in four phases—anamnesis, analytical incision, extraction of contradictions, and ethical suture—that emulate the rigor of a medical procedure applied to the realm of ideas. If this protocol is applied to the problem of the origin of art, anamnesis requires gathering a datum that traditional art history tends to overlook: intentional symbolic marks are not a late phenomenon of European Homo sapiens, but go back at least 100,000 years, as shown by the engraved ochres of Blombos and Diepkloof in South Africa. And if one accepts the interpretive hypothesis of the so-called Makapansgat pebble—a natural object with pareidolic facial features, found in association with remains of Australopithecus africanus and dated to around 3.3–3.0 million years ago—as a possible indication of proto-symbolization, the discussion could be pushed back to the Pliocene. It should be noted, however, that it is not a manufactured mask or a carved image, but an object whose symbolic status remains debated. The analytical incision then cuts into an inherited assumption: that art “begins” with the great figurative paintings of the Upper Paleolithic. The archaeological evidence shows that consistent iconic representation only appears widely around 45,000 years ago, although modern anatomy was present much earlier. The contradiction extracted is clear: Homo sapiens possessed the neural hardware for symbolization long before figurative art became a systematic practice. What was missing? The answer that follows from the S/Y/C framework is that Survival was already resolved in basic biological terms, but Completeness—the need to integrate experience into a coherent whole—had not yet found in Symbolon a sufficiently stable vehicle. Art, in this sense, is not born as aesthetic luxury but as a technology of coherence; a surgical intervention on the dispersion of experience.

This reading does not deny the ethnographic specificity that Fausto defends with such subtlety. On the contrary, it radicalizes it. If the agency of Amazonian images is a fact, this is because the human Symbolon does not operate in a vacuum, but on a substrate of Survival that demands fast and economical responses, and under the pressure of a Completeness that is not satisfied with mere technical utility. Classical theories of the evolution of the human mind, such as those of Steven Mithen, had already pointed out that the cognitive modularity of Homo sapiens allowed a “cognitive fluidity” between previously isolated domains. The S/Y/C model can be read as a deepening of that intuition: fluidity is not an accidental feature of the modern brain, but the phenomenal manifestation of a more general biological law that obliges every complex nervous system to resolve simultaneously the demands of persistence, symbolization, and integration. Ellen Dissanayake’s thesis on art as a “biological need” to make things special—a kind of Homo aestheticus—points in a convergent direction, but lacks the neurofunctional vocabulary that the S/Y/C model provides.

The ethical suture of this intervention does not consist in closing the debate, but in recognizing what kind of problem we are dealing with. Art is not an enigma to be resolved by appealing to a single origin—neither ritual, nor the brain, nor the struggle for survival—but a fold in which these three dimensions are knotted together. The Amazonian ritual image, the Blombos ochre mark, and the Chauvet painting are local, historically contingent solutions to the same structural tension: that of a nervous system that cannot limit itself to surviving and that, in order to survive in a specifically human way, needs to produce symbols that give it back a coherent image of its place in the world. The Surgical Philosophy, in this sense, does not “resolve” the origin of art; it displaces it from the question of cause to the question of function: what kind of operation on human experience does an object perform when it ceases to be a tool and becomes an operator of completeness? Fausto has shown, with an ethnographic density difficult to match, that this operation is real and transformative. The task that remains open—and that this text does not claim to close—is that of a neuroanthropology of art that takes the agency of images seriously without renouncing the biological specificity of the animal that produces them.


References

Dissanayake, E. (1992). Homo aestheticus: Where art comes from and why. Free Press.

Fausto, C. (2023). Ardis da arte: Imagem, agência e ritual na Amazônia [Artifacts of art: Image, agency, and ritual in Amazonia]. Editora da Universidade de São Paulo.

Fusaroli, R., et al. (2024). The evolution of symbolic artefacts: How function shapes form. Evolution and Human Behavior, *45*(3), 261–267. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.evolhumbehav.2024.03.003

Mallo, B. (2023). La construcción neuro-simbólica: Una aproximación al funcionamiento del cerebro desde una perspectiva multidisciplinar [The neuro-symbolic construction: An approach to brain functioning from a multidisciplinary perspective] [Doctoral dissertation, University of the Basque Country (UPV/EHU)]. https://core.ac.uk/works/151783061/

Mallo, B. (2026a). De la filosofía quirúrgica a la ley de coherencia biológica S/Y/C: Hacia una investigación sobre el origen del arte en la especie Homo [From surgical philosophy to the S/Y/C law of biological coherence: Toward an investigation into the origin of art in the Homo species]. BM Sapientia Press.

Mallo, B. (2026b). Arte y biología: Las bases del origen del arte [Art and biology: The bases of the origin of art]. BM Sapientia Press.

Mithen, S. (1996). The prehistory of the mind: A search for the origins of art, religion, and science. Thames and Hudson.


Autor / Author


Bernabé Mallo
 Doctor en Filosofía – Universidad del País Vasco / Euskal Herriko Unibertsitatea (UPV/EHU)
 Investigador independiente en neurofilosofía, evolución humana y origen del arte.
 

Bernabé Mallo
 PhD in Philosophy – University of the Basque Country / Euskal Herriko Unibertsitatea (UPV/EHU)
 Independent researcher in neurophilosophy, human evolution, and the origin of art.

Enlaces / Links


Página de autor Amazon / Amazon Author Page: https://www.amazon.com/author/bernabemallo
ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0001-9002-9728
Plataforma EHUenRed / Link EHUenRed:  https://www.ehu.eus/es/web/masterrak-eta-graduondokoak/red-latinoamericana-de-posgrados
Canal YouTube / Channel YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@neuroideas815
Canal YouTube / Channel YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCBsf6OZ482NjST6QA-hvYtQ
Publicaciones y proyectos en desarrollo / Publications and projects: 
https://www.amazon.com/author/bernabemallo
https://ehuenred.theglocal.network/ideas/el-origen-del-arte-en-el-cerebro-de-makapansgat-al-moma-del-primate-al-sapiens


 

El hacha, el símbolo y la herida abierta: una lectura quirúrgica de la agencia del arte desde la Amazonía

 

Bernabé Mallo

Doctor en Filosofía por la Universidad del País Vasco (UPV/EHU)
Investigador en neurofilosofía, evolución humana y origen del arte. / PhD in Philosophy – University of the Basque Country (UPV/EHU)
Researcher in neurophilosophy, human evolution, and the origins of art.

 

Una reseña de Ardis da Arte: Imagem, agência e ritual na Amazônia de Carlos Fausto

 

Hay libros que se leen y libros que operan. Ardis da Arte, del antropólogo Carlos Fausto, pertenece a la segunda categoría. Bajo la apariencia de un estudio etnográfico sobre imágenes y artefactos rituales en la Amazonía indígena, late una intervención más ambiciosa: la de un investigador que, tras décadas de convivencia con los Parakanã y los Kuikuro, se niega a tratar el arte como un adorno cultural sobreañadido a la vida social. Fausto describe un mundo en el que los bastones “se vuelven espíritus” y los humanos “se vuelven jaguares”; un mundo, en definitiva, donde las imágenes no representan: actúan. La pregunta que este libro deja suspendida en el aire no es qué significa una imagen, sino qué hace una imagen cuando es introducida en un campo de fuerzas rituales, y por qué los seres humanos hemos invertido tanta energía, desde el Paleolítico hasta hoy, en producir objetos que parecen tener voluntad propia.

Para quien investiga a caballo entre la neurociencia, la filosofía y la antropología del arte, la respuesta más honesta a esa pregunta no puede contentarse con una explicación culturalista. Fausto ofrece la evidencia empírica de que la agencia de las imágenes es un hecho etnográfico robusto; lo que no ofrece —porque no es su tarea— es una hipótesis sobre las condiciones neuronales y evolutivas que hacen posible que un artefacto de madera o una piedra pintada se conviertan en un operador ontológico. Es aquí donde el marco S/Y/C sobre el origen del arte en la especie Homo deja de ser un marco teórico entre otros y se revela como una herramienta de disección. La Ley de Coherencia Biológica S/Y/C que sostiene esta investigación postula que el sistema nervioso opera mediante una función primordial subdividida en tres subfunciones inseparables: Supervivencia (S) , como umbral físico que toda acción biológica debe atravesar; Symbolon (Y) , como capacidad de crear y manipular códigos compartidos que hacen de puente entre el mundo interno y el externo; y Completitud (C) , como fuerza motriz hacia la integración de las partes en un todo significante. Aplicada al material amazónico, esta tríada no funciona como una rejilla taxonómica, sino como un protocolo quirúrgico: la imagen ritual de Fausto es, en términos del modelo S/Y/C, una solución óptima en la que el Symbolon satisface las demandas de Completitud sin comprometer el sustrato de Supervivencia que sostiene la vida del grupo. El bastón que “se vuelve espíritu” no es una metáfora poética: es un dispositivo de coherencia biológica, un objeto que permite al sistema nervioso individual y al cuerpo social estabilizar una relación con el entorno que de otro modo sería intolerablemente dispersa.

La Filosofía Quirúrgica que articula esta investigación no es un juego retórico. Se despliega en cuatro fases —anamnesis, incisión analítica, extracción de contradicciones y sutura ética— que emulan el rigor de un procedimiento médico aplicado al ámbito de las ideas. Si se aplica ese protocolo al problema del origen del arte, la anamnesis obliga a recoger un dato que la historia del arte tradicional suele pasar por alto: la producción de marcas simbólicas intencionadas no es un fenómeno tardío del Homo sapiens europeo, sino que se remonta al menos a 100.000 años atrás, como demuestran los ocre grabados de Blombos y Diepkloof en Sudáfrica. Y si se acepta la hipótesis interpretativa del llamado guijarro de Makapansgat —un objeto natural con rasgos faciales pareidólicos, hallado en asociación con restos de Australopithecus africanus y fechado en torno a 3,3–3,0 millones de años— como posible indicio de una proto-simbolización, la discusión podría retrotraerse hasta el Plioceno. Conviene precisar, no obstante, que no se trata de una máscara fabricada ni de una imagen tallada, sino de un objeto cuyo estatus simbólico sigue siendo objeto de debate. La incisión analítica corta entonces sobre un supuesto heredado: que el arte “comienza” con las grandes pinturas figurativas del Paleolítico superior. La evidencia arqueológica muestra que la representación icónica consistente solo aparece de forma generalizada hace unos 45.000 años, aunque la anatomía moderna estaba presente desde mucho antes. La contradicción extraída es nítida: el Homo sapiens poseía el hardware neural para la simbolización mucho antes de que el arte figurativo se convirtiera en una práctica sistemática. ¿Qué faltaba? La respuesta que se desprende del marco S/Y/C es que la Supervivencia ya estaba resuelta en términos biológicos básicos, pero la Completitud —la necesidad de integrar la experiencia en un todo coherente— aún no encontraba en el Symbolon un vehículo suficientemente estable. El arte, en este sentido, no nace como lujo estético, sino como tecnología de la coherencia; una intervención quirúrgica sobre la dispersión de la experiencia.

Esta lectura no niega la especificidad etnográfica que Fausto defiende con tanta finura. Al contrario, la radicaliza. Si la agencia de las imágenes amazónicas es un hecho, ello se debe a que el Symbolon humano no opera en el vacío, sino sobre un sustrato de Supervivencia que exige respuestas rápidas y económicas, y bajo la presión de una Completitud que no se satisface con la mera utilidad técnica. Las teorías clásicas de la evolución de la mente humana, como las de Steven Mithen, ya habían señalado que la modularidad cognitiva del Homo sapiens permitió una “fluidez cognitiva” entre dominios antes aislados. El modelo S/Y/C puede leerse como una profundización de esa intuición: la fluidez no es un rasgo accidental del cerebro moderno, sino la manifestación fenoménica de una ley biológica más general que obliga a todo sistema nervioso complejo a resolver simultáneamente las demandas de persistencia, simbolización e integración. La tesis de Ellen Dissanayake sobre el arte como una “necesidad biológica” de hacer especiales las cosas —una suerte de Homo aestheticus— apunta en una dirección convergente, pero carece del vocabulario neurofuncional que el modelo S/Y/C aporta.

La sutura ética de esta intervención no consiste en cerrar el debate, sino en reconocer qué tipo de problema tenemos entre manos. El arte no es un enigma que se resuelva apelando a un único origen —ni el ritual, ni el cerebro, ni la lucha por la supervivencia—, sino un pliegue en el que esas tres dimensiones se anudan. La imagen ritual amazónica, la marca de ocre de Blombos y la pintura de Chauvet son soluciones locales, históricamente contingentes, a una misma tensión estructural: la de un sistema nervioso que no puede limitarse a sobrevivir y que, para sobrevivir de un modo específicamente humano, necesita producir símbolos que le devuelvan una imagen coherente de su lugar en el mundo. La Filosofía Quirúrgica, en este sentido, no “resuelve” el origen del arte; lo desplaza desde la pregunta por la causa hacia la pregunta por la función: ¿qué tipo de operación sobre la experiencia humana realiza un objeto cuando deja de ser un útil y se convierte en un operador de completitud? Fausto ha mostrado, con una densidad etnográfica difícil de igualar, que esa operación es real y transformadora. La tarea que queda abierta —y que este texto no pretende clausurar— es la de una neuroantropología del arte que tome en serio la agencia de las imágenes sin renunciar a la especificidad biológica del animal que las produce.


Referencias bibliográficas

Dissanayake, E. (1992). Homo aestheticus: Where art comes from and why. Free Press.

Fausto, C. (2023). Ardis da arte: Imagem, agência e ritual na Amazônia. Editora da Universidade de São Paulo.

Fusaroli, R., et al. (2024). The evolution of symbolic artefacts: How function shapes form. Evolution and Human Behavior, *45*(3), 261–267. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.evolhumbehav.2024.03.003

Mallo, B. (2023). La construcción neuro-simbólica: Una aproximación al funcionamiento del cerebro desde una perspectiva multidisciplinar [Tesis doctoral]. Universidad del País Vasco (UPV/EHU). https://core.ac.uk/works/151783061/

Mallo, B. (2026a). De la filosofía quirúrgica a la ley de coherencia biológica S/Y/C: Hacia una investigación sobre el origen del arte en la especie Homo. BM Sapientia Press.

Mallo, B. (2026b). Arte y biología: Las bases del origen del arte. BM Sapientia Press.

Mithen, S. (1996). The prehistory of the mind: A search for the origins of art, religion, and science. Thames and Hudson.


Autor / Author


Bernabé Mallo
 Doctor en Filosofía – Universidad del País Vasco / Euskal Herriko Unibertsitatea (UPV/EHU)
 Investigador independiente en neurofilosofía, evolución humana y origen del arte.
 

Bernabé Mallo
 PhD in Philosophy – University of the Basque Country / Euskal Herriko Unibertsitatea (UPV/EHU)
 Independent researcher in neurophilosophy, human evolution, and the origin of art.

Enlaces / Links


Página de autor Amazon / Amazon Author Page: https://www.amazon.com/author/bernabemallo
ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0001-9002-9728
Plataforma EHUenRed / Link EHUenRed:  https://www.ehu.eus/es/web/masterrak-eta-graduondokoak/red-latinoamericana-de-posgrados
Canal YouTube / Channel YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@neuroideas815
Canal YouTube / Channel YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCBsf6OZ482NjST6QA-hvYtQ
Publicaciones y proyectos en desarrollo / Publications and projects: 
https://www.amazon.com/author/bernabemallo
https://ehuenred.theglocal.network/ideas/el-origen-del-arte-en-el-cerebro-de-makapansgat-al-moma-del-primate-al-sapiens



  

 

miércoles, 11 de noviembre de 2026

The Beauty of Others: Ticio Escobar and the Dissolution of the Boundaries of Art

 

Bernabé Mallo

Doctor en Filosofía por la Universidad del País Vasco (UPV/EHU)
Investigador en neurofilosofía, evolución humana y origen del arte. / PhD in Philosophy – University of the Basque Country (UPV/EHU)
Researcher in neurophilosophy, human evolution, and the origins of art.

 

A review of La belleza de los otros: Arte indígena del Paraguay by Ticio Escobar (2012)


Introduction: the challenge of naming the unnameable

How can we speak of "art" in cultures where that word does not exist? How can we apply a category forged in the Western tradition —with its cult of the individual, its separation between form and function, its fetishisation of the unique work— to objects and practices that respond to radically different logics? This is the question running through La belleza de los otros, the foundational book by the Paraguayan critic, curator, and thinker Ticio Escobar, whose second, corrected and expanded edition appeared in 2012 (the original dates from 1993).

The challenge is enormous. As Rodrigo Montani notes in his review, using the term "art" to speak of the artefacts, attire, and ceremonies of the Indigenous peoples of Paraguay seems "an impossible task". Yet Escobar finds "good intellectual and political reasons to do so". His aim is clear: to survey the Indigenous art produced in Paraguay in order to highlight the presence of expressive universes "generally not inventoried in the country's artistic heritage".

What makes this book a singular contribution is not only its ethnographic erudition but its methodological wager: a "mestiza methodology", eclectic, navigating between art criticism and anthropology, combining first-hand ethnographic and museographic knowledge with the published information on each subject. It is, at bottom, an exercise in Surgical Philosophy avant la lettre: a precise cut into the surface of a badly posed problem in order to excise inherited dichotomies and suture a broader, more habitable conceptual framework.


The "mestiza methodology": a surgical cut into the dichotomies of art

The traditional model of Western art, Escobar notes, is characterised as a dualistic system that separates function and form, major art and minor art, art and craft. According to these dichotomies, popular art —associated with craft— is considered "minor art" because function predominates over form. Indigenous art, which Escobar places within popular art, subverts this hierarchy: its purpose is not a deficit but an essential dimension bound up with "the complete social experience of communities in religious, economic, political, and cultural terms".

The "mestiza methodology" Escobar proposes is not a soft eclecticism but a strategy of oblique approach. As he himself notes, "the mestiza methodology that the treatment of Indigenous artistic production demands hinders a coherent approach to its object, which is easier to access through oblique approximations and crossed perspectives than through direct paths". This oblique approach is, in essence, the surgical gesture: one cannot access the object head-on, with pre-established categories, because those categories distort it. One must circle it, cut in from the flanks, suture a new framework from which it can be understood.

Escobar does not reject the word "art"; he uses it strategically. "It remains fundamental to speak of Indigenous art", he writes, because it is the best term for translating a reality and a problem. Although it inevitably betrays, to some degree, Indo-American sociologies and cosmovisions, it enables "a poetics and a rhetoric capable of penetrating them" —something that terms such as "material culture", "craft", or "folklore" fail to achieve— and it is capable of "fissuring the ethnocidal and ecocidal narrative that has been and continues to be the condemnation of Indigenous peoples".


"The aesthetic is equivalent to the symbolic": the Y dimension in its purest state

The first chapter of the book, "El arte otro" ("The Other Art"), establishes the fundamental position that defines the whole work. Escobar asks: "Is it a piece of art? How can the edge of the aesthetic be defined in cultures that mix pure beauty with the encoded labours of worship, the prosaic efforts after food, and the complicated exercise of the social pact?"

After some provisional answers, he arrives at a conclusion that is at once a surrender and a discovery: "the aesthetic" is equivalent to "the symbolic". This equivalence permeates everything —art, religion, politics, law, science— and dissolves the boundaries that Western naturalism had erected between supposedly autonomous domains. The dichotomy between the utilitarian and the non-utilitarian does not hold in the works of "others". Indigenous "art" is not an individual creation, nor a transgressive innovation, nor an odd work. But it is art, precisely because it is symbolon: an act of recognition through shared codes that creates and confers meaning.

This equivalence between the aesthetic and the symbolic is the purest manifestation of the Y (Symbolon) dimension of our thesis. Symbolon is not an ornament of experience: it is the very fabric of social life. In Indigenous art, beauty is not an end in itself but the vehicle through which bonds with ancestors are actualised, relations with non-humans are negotiated, the person is constructed, and the cosmos is reproduced. Form is inseparable from meaning, and meaning is inseparable from communal life.


"Art and things": the S dimension in ritual materiality

The second chapter, "El arte y las cosas" ("Art and Things"), addresses movable artefacts —baskets, wood carvings, textiles, pottery, pyro-engraved gourds— and establishes a fundamental premise: "Indigenous art […] envelops things, shakes them out of the drowsiness of routine, and promotes in them the fulfilment of their transcendental and utilitarian, political and ludic functions".

This formulation is key to understanding the S (Survival) dimension in Indigenous art. Objects are not mere utensils, but neither are they autonomous works of art. They are operators of survival in a broad sense: they not only allow food to be transported or seeds to be stored, but sustain the social and cosmological life of the group. Their function is at once practical and transcendent. The basket being woven is not only used to gather fruits; its weave reproduces the order of the cosmos, its designs refer to animals and spirits, its form embodies a way of inhabiting the world.

Escobar's analysis of each technique —its forms, its designs, its colours, its underlying aesthetic principles, its symbolisms and mythical resonances— shows that materiality is the substrate of symbolic life. There is no symbol without a material body to support it. The survival of the group depends on those objects fulfilling their function, and that function is inseparable from their meaning.


"Art and rite": the C dimension in cosmic integration

The final chapter, "El arte y el rito" ("Art and Rite"), addresses the sensory dimension of ritual: "that moment which tears through everyday time and dilates space until it communicates with the impossible places inhabited by gods and the dead". Escobar pauses on four great ceremonies —the male initiation ritual of the Páĩ Taviterã, the jeroky ñembo'e dance-prayer of the Avá, the "great ceremony" or debylyby of the Ishir, and the arete guasu of the Chiriguano— and describes them in a prose that Montani calls "suggestive, intriguing, or wounding".

In ritual, art reaches its fullest expression as a force of cosmic integration. The Ishir debylyby, for example, is a "resounding synthesis" in which each group of men represents a group of divinities through the tihá, the characteristic cries that define the differences between divine species. "Emitted from the ankles of the Anábsoro, they are most powerful: in mythical times their mere force sufficed to strike birds dead […] mortally wound wild beasts and paralyse fish". Art, in ritual, does not represent power: it exercises it. It is the C (Wholeness) dimension in its most intense form: the integration of the human and the divine, the living and the dead, everyday time and mythical time, into a coherent and efficacious totality.


Connection with research on the origin of art (S/Y/C)

La belleza de los otros offers a privileged case study for observing the functioning of the Law of Biological Coherence S/Y/C (Mallo, 2023, 2025, 2026a, 2026b). The three dimensions unfold here with a clarity rarely found in Western aesthetics.

The S (Survival) dimension manifests in the functional materiality of objects and in the ritual efficacy of ceremonies. Indigenous art is not a contemplative luxury; it is a technology of social and cosmological survival. Baskets, carvings, songs, and dances sustain the life of the group, regulate relations with the environment, and guarantee the continuity of tradition.

The Y (Symbolon) dimension reaches here its most radical formulation: the aesthetic is equivalent to the symbolic. There is no autonomous domain of beauty separated from meaning. Beauty is the mode in which the symbol becomes present, is embodied, is shared. Symbolon is not a mental representation: it is an act of recognition carried out in the materiality of the object and the corporality of ritual.

The C (Wholeness) dimension is expressed in the cosmic integration of the rite. Indigenous art does not seek the individual masterpiece but lived totality: the community gathered, mythical time actualised, the entire cosmos present in a gesture, a song, an object. Wholeness is not a property of the work but a quality of experience when it manages to articulate all the dimensions of existence.

Surgical Philosophy finds in Escobar's "mestiza methodology" a methodological precedent. His oblique approach, his rejection of inherited dichotomies, his capacity to cut into the surface of the problem and suture a broader framework —all of this is an exercise in conceptual surgery. Escobar does not limit himself to applying categories; he dissects them, shows their historicity, their contingency, their particularity. And then he sutures a space where Indigenous art can be thought without being betrayed.


Final considerations: the beauty that refuses to be caught

La belleza de los otros is an unsettling book. It unsettles because it forces us to renounce our certainties about what art, beauty, authorship, and the work are. It unsettles because it shows us that our aesthetic categories are not universal but situated. It unsettles because, in the end, we cannot go back to looking at a basket, a mask, or a ritual dance with the same eyes with which we looked at them before.

Escobar does not offer a closed theory of Indigenous art. He offers something more valuable: a way of approaching that respects the irreducibility of its object. His "mestiza methodology" is an acknowledgement that there are realities which cannot be caught by inherited concepts, and that thought, when it is rigorous, must invent its own tools.

For our research on the origin of art, the lesson is clear: art was not born as an autonomous activity, separated from life, confined to a specialised domain. It was born —and continues to be born in Indigenous communities— as a total practice, integrated into economy, religion, politics, and ecology. Art is the language of symbolon, and symbolon is the fabric of social life. As long as there are communities that weave, sing, dance, and paint to sustain their world, art will continue to be what it always was: the fullest form of survival, symbol, and wholeness.


References

Escobar, T. (2012). La belleza de los otros: Arte indígena del Paraguay (2nd ed.). Servilibro.

Escobar, T. (2015). La belleza de los otros: Arte indígena del Paraguay. Edhasa.

Mallo, B. (2023). La construcción neuro-simbólica. Una aproximación al funcionamiento del cerebro desde una perspectiva multidisciplinar [Doctoral thesis, University of the Basque Country - Euskal Herriko Unibertsitatea]. ADDI Repository. http://hdl.handle.net/10810/62701

Mallo, B. (2025). Arte y biología: Una aproximación neurofilosófica al origen de la experiencia estética. https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0E8Y5WZMK

Mallo, B. (2025). Art and biology: A neurophilosophical approach to the origin of aesthetic experience. https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0E8Y6C2XN

Mallo, B. (2026a). De la filosofía quirúrgica a la ley de coherencia biológica S/Y/C: Hacia una investigación sobre el origen del arte en la especie Homo. https://isbn.bibna.gub.uy/catalogo.php?mode=detalle&nt=57196

Mallo, B. (2026a). De la filosofía quirúrgica a la ley de coherencia biológica S/Y/C: Hacia una investigación sobre el origen del arte en la especie Homo [Kindle edition]. https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0GYGTJD5C

Mallo, B. (2026b). From surgical philosophy to the law of biological coherence S/Y/C: Toward a study of the origin of art in the Homo lineage. https://isbn.bibna.gub.uy/catalogo.php?mode=detalle&nt=57197

Montani, R. (2014). Escobar Ticio, La belleza de los otros: arte indígena del Paraguay. Journal de la Société des Américanistes, *100*(1), 288–294. https://doi.org/10.4000/jsa.13816


Autor / Author


Bernabé Mallo
 Doctor en Filosofía – Universidad del País Vasco / Euskal Herriko Unibertsitatea (UPV/EHU)
 Investigador independiente en neurofilosofía, evolución humana y origen del arte.
 

Bernabé Mallo
 PhD in Philosophy – University of the Basque Country / Euskal Herriko Unibertsitatea (UPV/EHU)
 Independent researcher in neurophilosophy, human evolution, and the origin of art.

Enlaces / Links


Página de autor Amazon / Amazon Author Page: https://www.amazon.com/author/bernabemallo
ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0001-9002-9728
Plataforma EHUenRed / Link EHUenRed:  https://www.ehu.eus/es/web/masterrak-eta-graduondokoak/red-latinoamericana-de-posgrados
Canal YouTube / Channel YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@neuroideas815
Canal YouTube / Channel YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCBsf6OZ482NjST6QA-hvYtQ
Publicaciones y proyectos en desarrollo / Publications and projects: 
https://www.amazon.com/author/bernabemallo
https://ehuenred.theglocal.network/ideas/el-origen-del-arte-en-el-cerebro-de-makapansgat-al-moma-del-primate-al-sapiens


 

La belleza de los otros: Ticio Escobar y la disolución de las fronteras del arte

 

Bernabé Mallo

Doctor en Filosofía por la Universidad del País Vasco (UPV/EHU)
Investigador en neurofilosofía, evolución humana y origen del arte. / PhD in Philosophy – University of the Basque Country (UPV/EHU)
Researcher in neurophilosophy, human evolution, and the origins of art.

 

Una reseña de La belleza de los otros: Arte indígena del Paraguay de Ticio Escobar (2012)


Introducción: el desafío de nombrar lo innombrable

¿Cómo hablar de "arte" en culturas donde esa palabra no existe? ¿Cómo aplicar una categoría forjada en la tradición occidental —con su culto al individuo, su separación entre forma y función, su fetichización de la obra única— a objetos y prácticas que responden a lógicas radicalmente distintas? Esta es la pregunta que atraviesa La belleza de los otros, el libro fundamental del crítico, curador y pensador paraguayo Ticio Escobar, cuya segunda edición corregida y ampliada apareció en 2012 (la original es de 1993).

El desafío es enorme. Como señala Rodrigo Montani en su reseña, usar el término "arte" para hablar de los artefactos, atavíos y ceremonias de los indígenas del Paraguay parece "una tarea imposible" . Sin embargo, Escobar encuentra "buenas razones intelectuales y políticas para hacerlo" . Su objetivo es claro: levantar un panorama del arte indígena producido en el Paraguay para recalcar la presencia de universos expresivos "generalmente no inventariados en el patrimonio artístico del país" .

Lo que hace de este libro una contribución singular no es solo su erudición etnográfica, sino su apuesta metodológica: una "metodología mestiza", ecléctica, que navega entre la crítica de arte y la antropología, conjugando el conocimiento etnográfico y museográfico de primera mano con la información publicada sobre cada tema . Es, en el fondo, un ejercicio de Filosofía Quirúrgica avant la lettre: un corte preciso en la superficie de un problema mal planteado para extirpar las dicotomías heredadas y suturar un marco conceptual más amplio y habitable.


La "metodología mestiza": un corte quirúrgico en las dicotomías del arte

El modelo tradicional de arte occidental, señala Escobar, se caracteriza por ser un sistema dualista que separa función y forma, arte mayor y arte menor, arte y artesanía . Según estas dicotomías, el arte popular —asociado a la artesanía— se considera "arte menor" porque en él predomina la función sobre la forma . El arte indígena, que Escobar ubica dentro del arte popular, subvierte esta jerarquía: su finalidad no es un déficit, sino una dimensión esencial que tiene que ver con "la completa experiencia social de las comunidades en términos religiosos, económicos, políticos y culturales" .

La "metodología mestiza" que Escobar propone no es un eclecticismo blando, sino una estrategia de aproximación oblicua. Como él mismo señala, "la metodología mestiza que exige el tratamiento de lo artístico indígena dificulta una aproximación coherente a su objeto, al que es más fácil acceder a través de acercamientos oblicuos y perspectivas cruzadas que de caminos directos" . Esta aproximación oblicua es, en esencia, el gesto quirúrgico: no se puede acceder al objeto de frente, con las categorías preestablecidas, porque esas categorías lo distorsionan. Hay que rodearlo, cortar por los flancos, suturar un nuevo marco desde el que pueda ser comprendido.

Escobar no rechaza la palabra "arte"; la usa estratégicamente. "Sigue siendo fundamental hablar de arte indígena", escribe, porque es el mejor término para traducir una realidad y un problema . Aunque inevitablemente traiciona en algún grado las sociologías y cosmovisiones indoamericanas, habilita "una poética y una retórica capaz de penetrarlas" —algo que términos como "cultura material", "artesanía" o "folclore" no consiguen— y es capaz de "fisurar el relato etnocida y ecocida que ha sido y sigue siendo la condena de los indios" .


"Lo estético equivale a lo simbólico": la dimensión Y en estado puro

El primer capítulo del libro, "El arte otro", establece la posición fundamental que define toda la obra. Escobar se pregunta: "¿Es una pieza de arte? ¿Cómo puede definirse el borde de lo estético en culturas que mezclan la pura belleza con los trajines cifrados del culto, los prosaicos afanes en pos de la comida y el complicado ejercicio del pacto social?" .

Después de algunas respuestas provisionales, llega a una conclusión que es a la vez una rendición y un hallazgo: "lo estético" equivale a lo simbólico . Esta equivalencia lo impregna todo —arte, religión, política, derecho, ciencia— y disuelve las fronteras que el naturalismo occidental había erigido entre dominios supuestamente autónomos. La dicotomía entre lo utilitario y lo no utilitario no se sostiene en las obras de los "otros" . El "arte" indígena no es una creación individual ni una innovación transgresora ni una obra impar . Pero es arte, precisamente porque es symbolon: un acto de reconocimiento mediante códigos compartidos que crea y confiere significado.

Esta equivalencia entre lo estético y lo simbólico es la manifestación más pura de la dimensión Y (Symbolon) de nuestra tesis. El symbolon no es un adorno de la experiencia: es la trama misma de la vida social. En el arte indígena, la belleza no es un fin en sí mismo, sino el vehículo a través del cual se actualizan los vínculos con los antepasados, se negocian las relaciones con los no-humanos, se construye la persona y se reproduce el cosmos. La forma es inseparable del significado, y el significado es inseparable de la vida comunitaria.


"El arte y las cosas": la dimensión S en la materialidad ritual

El segundo capítulo, "El arte y las cosas", aborda los artefactos muebles —cestos, tallas en madera, textiles, alfarería, calabazas pirograbadas— y establece una premisa fundamental: "el arte indígena […] envuelve las cosas, las sacude de la modorra de la rutina y promueve en ellas el cumplimiento de sus funciones trascendentales y utilitarias, políticas y lúdicas" .

Esta formulación es clave para comprender la dimensión S (Supervivencia) en el arte indígena. Los objetos no son meros utensilios, pero tampoco son obras de arte autónomas. Son operadores de supervivencia en un sentido amplio: no solo permiten transportar alimentos o almacenar semillas, sino que sostienen la vida social y cosmológica del grupo. Su función es a la vez práctica y trascendente. El cesto que se teje no solo sirve para recoger frutos; su trama reproduce el orden del cosmos, sus diseños remiten a los animales y a los espíritus, su forma encarna una manera de habitar el mundo.

El análisis de Escobar de cada técnica —sus formas, sus diseños, sus colores, sus principios estéticos subyacentes, sus simbolismos y resonancias míticas— muestra que la materialidad es el sustrato de la vida simbólica. No hay símbolo sin cuerpo material que lo soporte. La supervivencia del grupo depende de que esos objetos cumplan su función, y esa función es inseparable de su significado.


"El arte y el rito": la dimensión C en la integración cósmica

El capítulo final, "El arte y el rito", aborda la dimensión sensible del ritual: "ese momento que rasga el tiempo cotidiano y dilata el espacio hasta comunicarlo con los lugares imposibles que habitan los dioses y los muertos" . Escobar se detiene en cuatro grandes ceremonias —el ritual de iniciación masculina de los páĩ taviterã, la danza-oración jeroky ñembo'e de los avás, la "gran ceremonia" o debylyby de los ishir y el arete guasu de los chiriguanos— y describe con una prosa que Montani califica de "sugerente, intrigante o hiriente" .

En el ritual, el arte alcanza su máxima expresión como fuerza de integración cósmica. El debylyby ishir, por ejemplo, es una "síntesis estruendosa" donde cada grupo de hombres representa a un grupo de divinidades a través de los tihá, los gritos característicos que definen las diferencias entre las especies divinas. "Emitidos desde los tobillos de los anábsoro, son poderosísimos: en tiempos míticos su sola fuerza bastaba para fulminar pájaros […] herir de muerte a las fieras y paralizar los peces" . El arte, en el ritual, no representa el poder: lo ejerce. Es la dimensión C (Completitud) en su forma más intensa: la integración de lo humano y lo divino, de los vivos y los muertos, del tiempo cotidiano y el tiempo mítico, en una totalidad coherente y eficaz.


Conexión con la investigación sobre el origen del arte (S/Y/C)

La belleza de los otros ofrece un caso de estudio privilegiado para observar el funcionamiento de la Ley de coherencia biológica S/Y/C (Mallo, 2023, 2025, 2026a, 2026b). Las tres dimensiones se despliegan aquí con una claridad que rara vez encontramos en la estética occidental.

La dimensión S (Supervivencia) se manifiesta en la materialidad funcional de los objetos y en la eficacia ritual de las ceremonias. El arte indígena no es un lujo contemplativo; es una tecnología de supervivencia social y cosmológica. Los cestos, las tallas, los cantos y las danzas sostienen la vida del grupo, regulan las relaciones con el entorno y garantizan la continuidad de la tradición.

La dimensión Y (Symbolon) alcanza aquí su formulación más radical: lo estético equivale a lo simbólico. No hay un dominio autónomo de la belleza separado del significado. La belleza es el modo en que el símbolo se hace presente, se encarna, se comparte. El symbolon no es una representación mental: es un acto de reconocimiento que se realiza en la materialidad del objeto y en la corporalidad del ritual.

La dimensión C (Completitud) se expresa en la integración cósmica del rito. El arte indígena no busca la obra maestra individual, sino la totalidad vivida: la comunidad reunida, el tiempo mítico actualizado, el cosmos entero presente en un gesto, en un canto, en un objeto. La completitud no es una propiedad de la obra, sino una cualidad de la experiencia cuando esta logra articular todas las dimensiones de la existencia.

La Filosofía Quirúrgica encuentra en la "metodología mestiza" de Escobar un precedente metodológico. Su aproximación oblicua, su rechazo de las dicotomías heredadas, su capacidad para cortar en la superficie del problema y suturar un marco más amplio —todo ello es un ejercicio de cirugía conceptual. Escobar no se limita a aplicar categorías; las disecciona, muestra su historicidad, su contingencia, su particularidad. Y luego sutura un espacio donde el arte indígena puede ser pensado sin ser traicionado.


Consideraciones finales: la belleza que no se deja atrapar

La belleza de los otros es un libro que incomoda. Incomoda porque nos obliga a renunciar a nuestras certezas sobre lo que es el arte, la belleza, la autoría, la obra. Incomoda porque nos muestra que nuestras categorías estéticas no son universales, sino situadas. Incomoda porque, al final, no podemos volver a mirar un cesto, una máscara o una danza ritual con los mismos ojos con que las mirábamos antes.

Escobar no ofrece una teoría cerrada del arte indígena. Ofrece algo más valioso: una forma de aproximación que respeta la irreductibilidad de su objeto. Su "metodología mestiza" es un reconocimiento de que hay realidades que no se dejan atrapar por los conceptos heredados, y que el pensamiento, cuando es riguroso, debe inventar sus propias herramientas.

Para nuestra investigación sobre el origen del arte, la lección es clara: el arte no nació como una actividad autónoma, separada de la vida, confinada a un dominio especializado. Nació —y sigue naciendo en las comunidades indígenas— como una práctica total, integrada en la economía, la religión, la política y la ecología. El arte es el lenguaje del symbolon, y el symbolon es la trama de la vida social. Mientras haya comunidades que tejan, canten, danzen y pinten para sostener su mundo, el arte seguirá siendo lo que siempre fue: la forma más plena de la supervivencia, el símbolo y la completitud.


Referencias bibliográficas

Escobar, T. (2012). La belleza de los otros: Arte indígena del Paraguay (2.ª ed.). Servilibro.

Escobar, T. (2015). La belleza de los otros: Arte indígena del Paraguay. Edhasa.

Mallo, B. (2023). La construcción neuro-simbólica. Una aproximación al funcionamiento del cerebro desde una perspectiva multidisciplinar [Tesis doctoral, Universidad del País Vasco - Euskal Herriko Unibertsitatea]. Repositorio ADDI. http://hdl.handle.net/10810/62701

Mallo, B. (2025). Arte y biología: Una aproximación neurofilosófica al origen de la experiencia estética. https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0E8Y5WZMK

Mallo, B. (2025). Art and biology: A neurophilosophical approach to the origin of aesthetic experience. https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0E8Y6C2XN

Mallo, B. (2026a). De la filosofía quirúrgica a la ley de coherencia biológica S/Y/C: Hacia una investigación sobre el origen del arte en la especie Homo. https://isbn.bibna.gub.uy/catalogo.php?mode=detalle&nt=57196

Mallo, B. (2026a). De la filosofía quirúrgica a la ley de coherencia biológica S/Y/C: Hacia una investigación sobre el origen del arte en la especie Homo [Versión Kindle]. https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0GYGTJD5C

Mallo, B. (2026b). From surgical philosophy to the law of biological coherence S/Y/C: Toward a study of the origin of art in the Homo lineage. https://isbn.bibna.gub.uy/catalogo.php?mode=detalle&nt=57197

Montani, R. (2014). Escobar Ticio, La belleza de los otros: arte indígena del Paraguay. Journal de la Société des Américanistes, *100*(1), 288–294. https://doi.org/10.4000/jsa.13816


Autor / Author


Bernabé Mallo
 Doctor en Filosofía – Universidad del País Vasco / Euskal Herriko Unibertsitatea (UPV/EHU)
 Investigador independiente en neurofilosofía, evolución humana y origen del arte.
 

Bernabé Mallo
 PhD in Philosophy – University of the Basque Country / Euskal Herriko Unibertsitatea (UPV/EHU)
 Independent researcher in neurophilosophy, human evolution, and the origin of art.

Enlaces / Links


Página de autor Amazon / Amazon Author Page: https://www.amazon.com/author/bernabemallo
ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0001-9002-9728
Plataforma EHUenRed / Link EHUenRed:  https://www.ehu.eus/es/web/masterrak-eta-graduondokoak/red-latinoamericana-de-posgrados
Canal YouTube / Channel YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@neuroideas815
Canal YouTube / Channel YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCBsf6OZ482NjST6QA-hvYtQ
Publicaciones y proyectos en desarrollo / Publications and projects: 
https://www.amazon.com/author/bernabemallo
https://ehuenred.theglocal.network/ideas/el-origen-del-arte-en-el-cerebro-de-makapansgat-al-moma-del-primate-al-sapiens

 


 

lunes, 26 de octubre de 2026

The Traffic of Souls: Descola and the Dissolution of the Boundary Between Nature and Culture

 

Bernabé Mallo

Doctor en Filosofía por la Universidad del País Vasco (UPV/EHU)
Investigador en neurofilosofía, evolución humana y origen del arte. / PhD in Philosophy – University of the Basque Country (UPV/EHU)
Researcher in neurophilosophy, human evolution, and the origins of art.

 

A review of "Beyond Nature and Culture: The Traffic of Souls" by Philippe Descola (2012)


Introduction: the end of an old dichotomy

For centuries, Western thought has organised its understanding of the world around a seemingly obvious distinction: on the one hand nature, the realm of physical facts, universal laws, bodies; on the other culture, the realm of norms, meanings, minds. This division, which seems evident to anyone raised within the modern tradition, is not universal. It is not natural. It is not obvious. It is, simply, one way among many of inhabiting the world.

The French anthropologist Philippe Descola, professor emeritus at the Collège de France, devotes his work precisely to demonstrating this: that the nature/culture dichotomy is a recent historical invention, a particular ontological configuration —naturalism— that has imposed itself in the West but does not exhaust the possibilities of human experience. In Beyond Nature and Culture: The Traffic of Souls, published in 2012 in HAU: Journal of Ethnographic Theory, Descola develops one of the most suggestive sections of his ambitious project: the analysis of how souls circulate between humans and non-humans in the ontologies of animism, and how this circulation dissolves the boundaries that naturalism had erected.

This review explores Descola's proposal, his four ontologies, the concept of the "traffic of souls," and its profound relevance for our research on the origin of art, the S/Y/C model, and Surgical Philosophy.


The four ontologies: a grammar of modes of being

To understand the scope of Descola's proposal, it must be situated within the framework of his major work, Par-delà nature et culture (2005), translated into English in 2013. There, Descola proposes that the ways in which human beings conceive the world are neither infinite nor arbitrary. They are organised around four fundamental ontologies —four "modes of identification"— that define how continuities and discontinuities between humans and non-humans are distributed.

These four ontologies are:

Animism: non-humans possess the same interiority as humans —soul, intentionality, consciousness— but differ in their corporality. Jaguars, plants, rivers are persons, but with different bodies. What distinguishes them from us is not their lack of soul, but their physical form, their habits, their capacities.

Totemism: humans and non-humans share both interiority and corporality, but are organised into discrete categories, each with a set of moral and physical properties that define its members. The beings of the world are distributed into "species" that are, at the same time, social and natural categories.

Naturalism: the modern Western ontology. Humans and non-humans share a corporality —we are made of the same matter, subject to the same physical laws— but differ radically in their interiority. Only humans possess culture, meaning, reflective consciousness. Other beings are pure nature.

Analogism: a regime of generalised discontinuities, where all beings in the world are different from one another, but are connected through networks of correspondences, analogies, and similarities. It is the ontology Descola associates with the cosmologies of China, West Africa, and the Andes.

These four ontologies are not "beliefs" that peoples have about the world. They are deep grammars that structure perception, action, and thought. They are the ways in which the world becomes intelligible, habitable, meaningful. And they are, above all, modes of relation: they do not describe what there is, but how we relate to what there is.


The traffic of souls: when interiority circulates

The article at hand, The Traffic of Souls, focuses on one of these ontologies —animism— and explores how it works in practice. The question Descola poses is the following: if in animism humans and non-humans share the same interiority, how is that continuity managed? How are souls distributed? What implications does this have for social life, for hunting, for eating, for death?

Descola's answer is that souls circulate. They are not permanently fixed to bodies, they are not stable properties of individuals. They are in constant transit: they pass from animals to humans, from humans to spirits, from the living to the dead, from the dead to the living. Social life, in animist societies, consists largely in managing that traffic: negotiating, regulating, channelling the flow of souls that traverses the cosmos.

Descola analyses this traffic through several ethnographic examples, mainly from Amazonia. In these societies, hunting is not a simple economic activity. It is a cosmological act of enormous gravity: killing an animal is killing a person, a relative, an affine. Shamans act as diplomats between worlds: they negotiate with animal spirits, offer compensation, establish pacts. The relationship between humans and animals is a social relationship, mediated by exchange, reciprocity, debt.

This traffic of souls has profound consequences for the understanding of the person. In animism, the person is not a closed, autonomous entity, defined by their individual body. It is a knot in a network of relations, a point of passage in a flow of souls that transcends it. Personal identity is not a private property, but a relational achievement: one becomes a person through one's bonds with other beings, human and non-human. Death is not the end of the person, but their transformation: the soul continues its journey, is reincarnated, becomes something else.


Makapansgat: the first traffic of souls

If animism holds that interiority circulates between humans and non-humans, can we extend that continuity to inanimate objects? Can a pebble have a soul? The question is not as far-fetched as it seems. In many animist ontologies, objects —stones, branches, mountains, rivers— are not mere aggregates of inert matter. They are beings with whom one can establish a relationship, to whom one can offer, with whom one can negotiate.

And here is where Makapansgat enters the scene. The famous reddish jasper pebble, collected by an australopithecine more than three million years ago and transported to their dwelling, is the oldest testimony we have of a gesture that seems to anticipate animism. Someone —a hominin, a remote ancestor— saw in that stone something more than a stone. They saw a face. And they did not only see it: they valued it, kept it, made it part of their home.

Can we call this animism? Perhaps that is premature. Animism, as Descola describes it, implies a complex cosmological system, with shamans, rituals, negotiations, an economy of exchanges between species. Makapansgat offers us nothing of that. It offers us, instead, a minimal gesture: the collection of an inanimate object to which a meaning is attributed that transcends its immediate utility.

But that minimal gesture is, perhaps, the germ of what would later become animism. If animism consists of extending interiority beyond the human species, the australopithecine of Makapansgat was the first to take that step. We do not know whether they believed the stone had a soul, or whether they considered it a relative, or whether they expected something from it. We know they picked it up, carried it with them, kept it. And that act —the act of keeping an object for what it means, not for what it serves— is the founding act of all symbolic relation with the world.

We can expand that first act. We can imagine the australopithecine finding the stone, looking at it, recognising a face in it. We can imagine them carrying it to their group, showing it to others, leaving it in a special place in their dwelling. We can imagine that, around that stone, the first stories were woven, the first shared gestures, the first collective meanings. We have no proof of any of this. But the stone is there, and its presence authorises us to think that something happened.

The traffic of souls, in Descola, is a practical reality: it is lived, negotiated, managed every day. The hunter who kills an animal negotiates with its spirit. The shaman who travels to the world of the dead establishes pacts with the ancestors. Is not the gatherer who finds an object and keeps it for the future within their dwelling an incipient form of that same traffic? Are they not establishing, with that object, a relationship that transcends mere utility? Are they not, in a certain way, animating inert matter?

Perhaps so. Perhaps animism is not a late invention of complex societies, but a primordial disposition of the human nervous system: the tendency to attribute interiority, agency, intention, to everything around us. Studies on infant cognition and on social perception suggest that this disposition is early and universal. Young children attribute life to objects; adults attribute it to animals, to machines, to institutions. Animism, from this perspective, would not be a "primitive belief," but a biological tendency that cultures shape in different ways.

Makapansgat would be, then, the first testimony of that tendency. The first object kept not for its utility, but for its meaning. The first indication that the human nervous system was already disposed to see souls where there is only matter.


Souls as operators of continuity

The concept of the "traffic of souls" is, at bottom, an analytical tool for thinking about the continuity between humans and non-humans. In naturalism, that continuity is thought in physical terms: we are all made of the same matter, we are all part of nature. In animism, it is thought in spiritual terms: we all share the same interiority, the same capacity to feel, to want, to signify.

But the crucial difference is that, in animism, that continuity is not a theoretical abstraction. It is a practical reality: it is lived, negotiated, managed every day. The hunter who kills an animal knows they are killing a person. The shaman who travels to the spirit world knows they are visiting relatives. The child who learns to respect animals knows they are learning to respect beings that have a soul, that suffer, that remember. And the australopithecine who picks up a stone shaped like a face knows —or intuits— that they are establishing a relationship with something that transcends matter.

This lived continuity has profound implications for ethics. If animals are persons, killing them is a morally grave act, requiring justification, compensation, ritual. If plants have a soul, gathering them is an act of reciprocity, not of simple extraction. If stones can have a face, picking them up is an act of recognition, not of mere appropriation. The relationship with the environment is not instrumental, but social: it is mediated by norms, obligations, affections.


Connection with research on the origin of art (S/Y/C)

Descola's proposal offers a conceptual framework of enormous value for our research on the Law of Biological Coherence S/Y/C (Mallo, 2023, 2025, 2026a, 2026b). His four ontologies, and in particular animism and the traffic of souls, illuminate crucial aspects of the three dimensions of our thesis.

The S (Survival) dimension manifests in the centrality of hunting in animist societies. Material survival —obtaining food, protecting oneself from predators— is a constant concern. But in animism, survival is not only a matter of technical efficiency. It is a cosmological question: in order to survive, one must negotiate with spirits, maintain good relations with animals, respect the rules of the traffic of souls. Survival is embodied in a system of relations that transcends the purely biological. And at Makapansgat, survival is expanded: it is no longer only that of the body, but that of meaning, of the bond, of the group's memory.

The Y (Symbolon) dimension is illuminated by the notion of shared interiority. In animism, all beings —humans, animals, plants, spirits, and perhaps also stones— possess an interiority that manifests through shared codes: language, rituals, dreams, shamanic visions. Symbolon, in our thesis, is the act of recognition through shared codes. In animism, that recognition extends beyond the species: we recognise animals as persons, we recognise ourselves in them, we bind ourselves through a common ground of interiority. And at Makapansgat, recognition extends beyond the living: the australopithecine recognises a face in a stone, establishes a bond with an inanimate object, inaugurates a mode of relation that is no longer purely instrumental.

The C (Wholeness) dimension manifests in the search for cosmic balance. The traffic of souls is not chaos; it is a regulated system, an economy of exchanges that seeks to maintain balance between humans, animals, spirits, and the dead. Wholeness, in animism, is the harmony of the cosmos, the integration of all beings into a coherent whole where each has its place, its obligations, its rights. This search for wholeness is analogous to the one that, in naturalism, is expressed in the idea of natural law or ecological balance. But in animism, wholeness is not an objective fact: it is a fragile achievement, constantly threatened by excess, violence, transgression. And at Makapansgat, wholeness is hinted at: the object collected, kept, conserved, is an attempt to close a circle, to integrate the strange into one's own, to give a place to what had none.

Surgical Philosophy invites us to make a precise analytical cut in Descola's work. It is not about accepting his four ontologies as a definitive taxonomy without more —Descola himself insists that they are models for thinking, not eternal essences—. It is about recognising that his proposal opens a space of comparison that the nature/culture dichotomy had closed off. Surgical Philosophy allows us to dissect that dichotomy, to show its historicity, its contingency, its particularity. And it allows us to suture a broader framework where the different ontologies —animism, totemism, naturalism, analogism— can be thought on equal footing, without evolutionary hierarchies, without presuppositions of superiority. And within that framework, Makapansgat ceases to be a mere archaeological curiosity and becomes a milestone in the history of the relationship between human beings and the world.


Implications for the study of the origin of art

Descola's proposal has profound implications for research on the origin of art. If the nature/culture dichotomy is not universal, then the categories with which we have thought about prehistoric art —"representation," "symbol," "expression"— may be biased by naturalism.

In naturalism, art is a cultural activity that is distinguished from nature. The artist is a human subject who creates objects that represent the natural world or express their cultural interiority. Cave paintings, from this perspective, are representations of animals: images that "stand for" real animals, that symbolise them, that communicate them.

But in animism, this distinction is blurred. Paintings of animals are not representations of animals: they are manifestations of their presence, vehicles of their agency, indexes of their soul. The artist does not "represent" a bison: they establish a relationship with it, summon it, negotiate with it, incorporate it into the human world. Art, in animism, is not an activity separated from social and cosmological life. It is a practice of the traffic of souls, a way of managing relations with non-humans.

This perspective invites us to reread prehistoric art from a different angle. The paintings of Lascaux or Chauvet are not simply "representations" of Pleistocene fauna. They are cosmological acts: hunting rituals, negotiations with spirits, vehicles of agency. Palaeolithic artists were not "artists" in the modern sense of the term. They were shamans, hunters, persons who used images to act upon the world, to establish relationships, to manage the traffic of souls. And Makapansgat, three million years earlier, is the first testimony of that gesture: the gesture of establishing a relationship with an object, of attributing meaning to it, of incorporating it into the human world.

Descola's proposal reminds us that art, in its origin, was not an autonomous activity, separated from life, confined to a specialised domain. It was a total practice, integrated into economy, religion, politics, ecology. Art was, in animism, the language of the traffic of souls. And that language began to be stammered, perhaps, with the gesture of an australopithecine who picked up a stone and kept it.


Final considerations: art as traffic of relations

Philippe Descola's work is one of those contributions that transform our gaze on the world and on ourselves. His analysis of the traffic of souls forces us to rethink the categories with which we have organised experience: nature and culture, human and non-human, body and soul, subject and object. He shows us that these categories are not universal, but historical, contingent, situated.

For our research on the origin of art, the lesson is clear: art was not born as an activity of representation, but as a practice of relation. It was not born from the need to copy the world, but from the need to negotiate with it. Art was, from its origins, a traffic of souls, an exchange between humans and non-humans, a bridge between worlds. And Makapansgat, with its stone shaped like a face, is the first vestige of that traffic: the gesture of a being who, for the first time, saw in inert matter an interlocutor.

Descola taught us to see ontologies as grammars of existence. We add: art is the language of those grammars. Without the traffic of souls, there would be no art. Without art, there would be no way to manage the traffic. Art is, at its root, the form of relation. And relation, like the Makapansgat pebble, can begin with a simple gesture: picking up a stone and keeping it.


References

Descola, P. (2012). Beyond nature and culture: The traffic of souls (J. Lloyd, Trans.). HAU: Journal of Ethnographic Theory, *2*(1), 473–500. https://doi.org/10.14318/hau2.1.021

Descola, P. (2013). Beyond nature and culture (J. Lloyd, Trans.). University of Chicago Press. (Original work published 2005)

Mallo, B. (2023). La construcción neuro-simbólica. Una aproximación al funcionamiento del cerebro desde una perspectiva multidisciplinar [Doctoral thesis, University of the Basque Country - Euskal Herriko Unibertsitatea]. ADDI Repository. http://hdl.handle.net/10810/62701

Mallo, B. (2025). Arte y biología: Una aproximación neurofilosófica al origen de la experiencia estética. https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0E8Y5WZMK

Mallo, B. (2025). Art and biology: A neurophilosophical approach to the origin of aesthetic experience. https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0E8Y6C2XN

Mallo, B. (2026a). De la filosofía quirúrgica a la ley de coherencia biológica S/Y/C: Hacia una investigación sobre el origen del arte en la especie Homo. https://isbn.bibna.gub.uy/catalogo.php?mode=detalle&nt=57196

Mallo, B. (2026a). De la filosofía quirúrgica a la ley de coherencia biológica S/Y/C: Hacia una investigación sobre el origen del arte en la especie Homo [Kindle edition]. https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0GYGTJD5C

Mallo, B. (2026b). From surgical philosophy to the law of biological coherence S/Y/C: Toward a study of the origin of art in the Homo lineage. https://isbn.bibna.gub.uy/catalogo.php?mode=detalle&nt=57197


Autor / Author


Bernabé Mallo
 Doctor en Filosofía – Universidad del País Vasco / Euskal Herriko Unibertsitatea (UPV/EHU)
 Investigador independiente en neurofilosofía, evolución humana y origen del arte.
 

Bernabé Mallo
 PhD in Philosophy – University of the Basque Country / Euskal Herriko Unibertsitatea (UPV/EHU)
 Independent researcher in neurophilosophy, human evolution, and the origin of art.

Enlaces / Links


Página de autor Amazon / Amazon Author Page: https://www.amazon.com/author/bernabemallo
ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0001-9002-9728
Plataforma EHUenRed / Link EHUenRed:  https://www.ehu.eus/es/web/masterrak-eta-graduondokoak/red-latinoamericana-de-posgrados
Canal YouTube / Channel YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@neuroideas815
Canal YouTube / Channel YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCBsf6OZ482NjST6QA-hvYtQ
Publicaciones y proyectos en desarrollo / Publications and projects: 
https://www.amazon.com/author/bernabemallo
https://ehuenred.theglocal.network/ideas/el-origen-del-arte-en-el-cerebro-de-makapansgat-al-moma-del-primate-al-sapiens