Bernabé Mallo
Doctor en Filosofía por la Universidad del País Vasco (UPV/EHU)
Investigador
en neurofilosofía, evolución humana y origen del arte. / PhD in
Philosophy – University of the Basque Country (UPV/EHU)
Researcher in neurophilosophy, human evolution, and the origins of art.
A review of Ardis da Arte: Imagem, agência e ritual na Amazônia by Carlos Fausto
Some books are read, and some books operate. Ardis da Arte, by the anthropologist Carlos Fausto, belongs to the second category. Beneath the appearance of an ethnographic study of images and ritual artifacts in Indigenous Amazonia, there lies a more ambitious intervention: that of a researcher who, after decades of living with the Parakanã and the Kuikuro, refuses to treat art as a cultural ornament added onto social life. Fausto describes a world in which staffs “become spirits” and humans “become jaguars”; a world, in short, where images do not represent: they act. The question that this book leaves hanging in the air is not what an image means, but what an image does when it is introduced into a field of ritual forces, and why human beings have invested so much energy, from the Paleolithic to the present, in producing objects that seem to have a will of their own.
For a researcher working at the intersection of neuroscience, philosophy, and the anthropology of art, the most honest answer to that question cannot be content with a culturalist explanation. Fausto offers empirical evidence that the agency of images is a robust ethnographic fact; what he does not offer—because it is not his task—is a hypothesis about the neural and evolutionary conditions that make it possible for a wooden artifact or a painted stone to become an ontological operator. It is here that the S/Y/C framework on the origin of art in the Homo species ceases to be one theoretical framework among others and reveals itself as a dissecting tool. The S/Y/C Law of Biological Coherence that sustains this research postulates that the nervous system operates through a primordial function subdivided into three inseparable subfunctions: Survival (S) , as the physical threshold that every biological action must cross; Symbolon (Y) , as the capacity to contain, create, and manipulate shared codes that bridge the internal and external worlds; and Completeness (C) , as the driving force toward the integration of parts into a meaningful whole. Applied to the Amazonian material, this triad does not function as a taxonomic grid but as a surgical protocol: Fausto’s ritual image is, in terms of the S/Y/C model, an optimal solution in which Symbolon satisfies the demands of Completeness without compromising the substrate of Survival that sustains the group’s life. The staff that “becomes a spirit” is not a poetic metaphor: it is a device of biological coherence, an object that allows the individual nervous system and the social body to stabilize a relationship with the environment that would otherwise be intolerably dispersed.
The Surgical Philosophy that articulates this research is not a rhetorical game. It unfolds in four phases—anamnesis, analytical incision, extraction of contradictions, and ethical suture—that emulate the rigor of a medical procedure applied to the realm of ideas. If this protocol is applied to the problem of the origin of art, anamnesis requires gathering a datum that traditional art history tends to overlook: intentional symbolic marks are not a late phenomenon of European Homo sapiens, but go back at least 100,000 years, as shown by the engraved ochres of Blombos and Diepkloof in South Africa. And if one accepts the interpretive hypothesis of the so-called Makapansgat pebble—a natural object with pareidolic facial features, found in association with remains of Australopithecus africanus and dated to around 3.3–3.0 million years ago—as a possible indication of proto-symbolization, the discussion could be pushed back to the Pliocene. It should be noted, however, that it is not a manufactured mask or a carved image, but an object whose symbolic status remains debated. The analytical incision then cuts into an inherited assumption: that art “begins” with the great figurative paintings of the Upper Paleolithic. The archaeological evidence shows that consistent iconic representation only appears widely around 45,000 years ago, although modern anatomy was present much earlier. The contradiction extracted is clear: Homo sapiens possessed the neural hardware for symbolization long before figurative art became a systematic practice. What was missing? The answer that follows from the S/Y/C framework is that Survival was already resolved in basic biological terms, but Completeness—the need to integrate experience into a coherent whole—had not yet found in Symbolon a sufficiently stable vehicle. Art, in this sense, is not born as aesthetic luxury but as a technology of coherence; a surgical intervention on the dispersion of experience.
This reading does not deny the ethnographic specificity that Fausto defends with such subtlety. On the contrary, it radicalizes it. If the agency of Amazonian images is a fact, this is because the human Symbolon does not operate in a vacuum, but on a substrate of Survival that demands fast and economical responses, and under the pressure of a Completeness that is not satisfied with mere technical utility. Classical theories of the evolution of the human mind, such as those of Steven Mithen, had already pointed out that the cognitive modularity of Homo sapiens allowed a “cognitive fluidity” between previously isolated domains. The S/Y/C model can be read as a deepening of that intuition: fluidity is not an accidental feature of the modern brain, but the phenomenal manifestation of a more general biological law that obliges every complex nervous system to resolve simultaneously the demands of persistence, symbolization, and integration. Ellen Dissanayake’s thesis on art as a “biological need” to make things special—a kind of Homo aestheticus—points in a convergent direction, but lacks the neurofunctional vocabulary that the S/Y/C model provides.
The ethical suture of this intervention does not consist in closing the debate, but in recognizing what kind of problem we are dealing with. Art is not an enigma to be resolved by appealing to a single origin—neither ritual, nor the brain, nor the struggle for survival—but a fold in which these three dimensions are knotted together. The Amazonian ritual image, the Blombos ochre mark, and the Chauvet painting are local, historically contingent solutions to the same structural tension: that of a nervous system that cannot limit itself to surviving and that, in order to survive in a specifically human way, needs to produce symbols that give it back a coherent image of its place in the world. The Surgical Philosophy, in this sense, does not “resolve” the origin of art; it displaces it from the question of cause to the question of function: what kind of operation on human experience does an object perform when it ceases to be a tool and becomes an operator of completeness? Fausto has shown, with an ethnographic density difficult to match, that this operation is real and transformative. The task that remains open—and that this text does not claim to close—is that of a neuroanthropology of art that takes the agency of images seriously without renouncing the biological specificity of the animal that produces them.
References
Dissanayake, E. (1992). Homo aestheticus: Where art comes from and why. Free Press.
Fausto, C. (2023). Ardis da arte: Imagem, agência e ritual na Amazônia [Artifacts of art: Image, agency, and ritual in Amazonia]. Editora da Universidade de São Paulo.
Fusaroli, R., et al. (2024). The evolution of symbolic artefacts: How function shapes form. Evolution and Human Behavior, *45*(3), 261–267. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.evolhumbehav.2024.03.003
Mallo, B. (2023). La construcción neuro-simbólica: Una aproximación al funcionamiento del cerebro desde una perspectiva multidisciplinar [The neuro-symbolic construction: An approach to brain functioning from a multidisciplinary perspective] [Doctoral dissertation, University of the Basque Country (UPV/EHU)]. https://core.ac.uk/works/151783061/
Mallo, B. (2026a). De la filosofía quirúrgica a la ley de coherencia biológica S/Y/C: Hacia una investigación sobre el origen del arte en la especie Homo [From surgical philosophy to the S/Y/C law of biological coherence: Toward an investigation into the origin of art in the Homo species]. BM Sapientia Press.
Mallo, B. (2026b). Arte y biología: Las bases del origen del arte [Art and biology: The bases of the origin of art]. BM Sapientia Press.
Mithen, S. (1996). The prehistory of the mind: A search for the origins of art, religion, and science. Thames and Hudson.
Autor / Author
Bernabé Mallo
Doctor en Filosofía – Universidad del País Vasco / Euskal Herriko Unibertsitatea (UPV/EHU)
Investigador independiente en neurofilosofía, evolución humana y origen del arte.
Bernabé Mallo
PhD in Philosophy – University of the Basque Country / Euskal Herriko Unibertsitatea (UPV/EHU)
Independent researcher in neurophilosophy, human evolution, and the origin of art.
Enlaces / Links
Página de autor Amazon / Amazon Author Page: https://www.amazon.com/author/bernabemallo
ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0001-9002-9728
Plataforma EHUenRed / Link EHUenRed: https://www.ehu.eus/es/web/masterrak-eta-graduondokoak/red-latinoamericana-de-posgrados
Canal YouTube / Channel YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@neuroideas815
Canal YouTube / Channel YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCBsf6OZ482NjST6QA-hvYtQ
Publicaciones y proyectos en desarrollo / Publications and projects:
https://www.amazon.com/author/bernabemallo
https://ehuenred.theglocal.network/ideas/el-origen-del-arte-en-el-cerebro-de-makapansgat-al-moma-del-primate-al-sapiens
No hay comentarios:
Publicar un comentario